Original research

We Checked 19 Lighting Guides. Here's Where They Disagree.

In short: every guide we checked agrees that a chandelier belongs 30–34″ above a dining table with an 8 ft ceiling. They split on what to do with taller ceilings, where advice for the same kitchen island ranges from 30″ to 42″, and on how wide a chandelier should be, with three different rules in use.

10 of 10dining guides include 30–34″ above the table
12″spread in island pendant advice for a 10 ft ceiling (30–42″)
3different rules for chandelier width: ½–⅔, ½–¾ and ⅔–¾ of the table
2 of 19guides give different numbers in different parts of the same page

Lighting advice online is everywhere, and it rarely says where its numbers come from. We wanted to know how much the published guidance actually agrees. So we read 19 guides to hanging chandeliers over dining tables and pendants over kitchen islands, and recorded every number they give. All of the data is below and in a CSV file you're free to reuse.

1. Chandelier height over a dining table: broad agreement

For an 8 ft ceiling, seven of the ten dining guides recommend 30–36″ from the tabletop to the bottom of the chandelier. Two stop at 34″, and one New Zealand retailer gives 750–900 mm (about 29½–35½″). Every one of them includes the range from 30″ to 34″, so that's the safe zone.

Recommended distance from tabletop to the bottom of the chandelier, 8 ft ceiling. The shaded band is the range every guide includes. Hover or tap a row for notes.

Most also agree on taller ceilings: six of the ten add about 3″ for every foot above 8 ft. One starts adding only above 9 ft, one says "a few inches" without a number, and two give no adjustment at all.

2. Pendants over a kitchen island: agreement until the ceiling gets taller

All nine island guides give the same headline: 30–36″ above the countertop. The agreement ends with a 10 ft ceiling. Four guides add 3″ per foot, which puts the pendants at 36–42″. One shifts gradually to 34–36″. Two say to stay at 30–36″ and use a longer cord instead. Two don't say.

Recommended distance from countertop to the bottom of the pendants with a 10 ft ceiling. The shaded band is what all nine guides say for an 8 ft ceiling.

Both camps have a point. Raising pendants keeps them in proportion with a tall room. Keeping them low keeps the light on the counter, where you need it. Our view: raise them, but no more than the top of the range you're comfortable working under. The island calculator uses the 3″-per-foot rule.

3. Chandelier width: three different rules

Six dining guides give a width rule, and they use three different fractions of the table's width: ½ to ⅔, ½ to ¾, and ⅔ to ¾. On a typical 42″ table, that's the difference between a 21″ and a 31½″ chandelier. Only one guide adds a clearance rule, keeping the fixture at least 12″ narrower than the table.

Recommended chandelier width for a 42″ wide table, worked out from each guide's rule.

On a 42″ table, a chandelier ¾ of the table's width leaves only about 5″ on each side, close enough that people bump it when they stand. The chandelier calculator uses ½ to ⅔ and keeps the fixture at least 6″ inside each edge.

4. Where everyone agrees: pendant spacing

Eight of the nine island guides space pendants 24–30″ apart (two allow up to 32″ or 36″). Five say to keep the end pendants at least 6″ from the island's ends. The ninth uses a different rule: the gap between pendants should equal one pendant's width. Our spacing guide explains a method that satisfies both.

5. Guides that disagree with themselves

Two of the 19 pages give different numbers in different places. One dining guide says 30–36″ in its text but 30–32″ in its own chart. One island guide says 30–36″ in the body, 30–32″ in its key takeaways and 28–36″ in its FAQ. That's a sign of pages edited in pieces, and a reason to treat any single guide with caution.

What this means if you're hanging a light

Every rule our calculators use, and where it comes from, is on our How we calculate page.

How we did this

The data

Dining chandeliers: distance from tabletop to bottom of fixture, 8 ft ceiling
GuideHeightTaller ceilingsWidth rule
Lighting New York30–36″+3″ per footNot stated
Bellona USA30–34″ (28–32″ round tables)+3″ per foot above 9 ftNot stated
James+James30–36″"A few inches" per footNot confirmed
Chairish30–36″+3″ per footNot stated
Seus Lighting30–36″+3″ per foot½–⅔ of table width
EDISHINE30–36″ (its chart: 30–32″)+3″ per foot½–¾ of table width
DecorLane30–34″+3″ per foot50–75% of table width
MEET LIGHTING30–36″+3″ per foot½–⅔, at least 12″ narrower than the table
Modern Lights30–36″None given½–⅔ of table width
The Lighting Centre (NZ)750–900 mm (29½–35½″)None given⅔–¾ of table width
Kitchen island pendants: distance from countertop to bottom of pendant
Guide8 ft ceilingTaller ceilingsSpacing
Quoizel30–36″+3″ per foot (10 ft: 36–42″)24–30″ between fixtures, 6″+ from edges
Cedar & Moss30–36″Not stated24–30″ apart
Modern Chandelier30–36″ (8 ft: 30–32″)9 ft: 32–34″, 10 ft: 34–36″, 11–12 ft: 36–40″24–30″ center to center, 6″+ from ends
IndochinaLight30–36″+3″ per foot up to 10 ft (36–42″)24–30″ center to center
ROWABI30–36″ (also 30–32″ and 28–36″)+3″ per footAbout 30″ apart, 6″+ from edges
Homebaa30–36″+3″ per foot (10 ft: 36–42″)24–32″ center to center, 6–12″ from ends
LightsLux30–36″No fixed adjustment24–30″ center to center
The Everything Depot30–36″Keep 30–36″24–30″ center to center
Morsale30–36″Not statedGap equals pendant width

Use this data

The data is free to reuse under a CC BY 4.0 license: credit Light Sizer and link to this page. Download the CSV file. Found a guide we should add, or a number that has changed? We'll update the study and the date at the top.